LIVE PROTOCOL
EET--:--:-- edition--.--.--

Pakistan and Afghanistan give sharply different accounts of deadly cross-border air strikes

Pakistan and Afghanistan give sharply different accounts of deadly cross-border air strikes

Pakistan says it carried out strikes that destroyed four targets and killed 26 militants, describing the operation as a response to recent terrorist attacks inside the country and saying it hit border hideouts, an ammunition cache and a training centre. Afghanistan's Taliban government gives a vastly different account, with officials in Kabul saying the strikes hit three provinces and killed 13 people, including 11 children. It is the first major flare-up since February, when border fighting left hundreds of people dead, and comes after the two nations agreed a ceasefire last October.

A fresh round of cross-border air strikes has reignited tensions between Pakistan and Afghanistan, with the two sides offering sharply different accounts of what was hit and who was killed. Pakistan says its forces carried out an operation that destroyed four targets and killed 26 militants. It has framed the strikes as a direct response to recent terrorist attacks inside the country, presenting the action as a security measure aimed at those it blames for the violence on its soil.

According to Pakistan's account, the operation was focused on specific militant infrastructure close to the border. Officials say the strikes targeted border hideouts, an ammunition cache and a training centre. By describing the targets in those terms, Pakistan has cast the strikes as precise blows against armed groups rather than a broad assault, and has tied the timing of the operation to the attacks it says were carried out against it in the preceding period.

Afghanistan's Taliban government has given a vastly different picture of the same events. Officials in Kabul reject the framing of the strikes as narrow hits on militant sites, and instead describe a heavy civilian cost. Their account directly contradicts the Pakistani version, turning the episode into a dispute not only over who was responsible but over the very nature of what the strikes destroyed and whom they killed.

In Kabul's telling, the Pakistani strikes hit three separate provinces. Officials there say 13 people were killed, including 11 children. That figure places the deaths overwhelmingly among the young, and it stands in stark contrast to Pakistan's claim that those killed were militants. The two sets of numbers cannot easily be reconciled, and each government is presenting its own count as the accurate record of what happened.

The gap between the two accounts is at the heart of the latest dispute. Where Pakistan speaks of 26 militants and a set of destroyed military-style targets, the Taliban government speaks of 13 dead, most of them children, spread across three provinces. The competing claims leave a wide and unresolved space between an operation described as a strike on armed fighters and one described as having killed civilians, and neither side has accepted the other's version.

This latest escalation marks the first major flare-up between the two neighbours since February. That earlier period of border fighting was severe, leaving hundreds of people dead before the situation eased. The return to strikes and counter-claims now revives the prospect of a renewed and dangerous cycle along the frontier, raising fears that the relative calm of recent months could give way to sustained confrontation once again.

The renewed violence is all the more striking because the two nations had agreed a ceasefire last October. That understanding had appeared to hold through the worst of the earlier clashes and into the calmer stretch that followed. The current strikes, and the bitter disagreement over their human cost, now test whether that ceasefire can survive, leaving the border between Pakistan and Afghanistan once more at the centre of a deadly and contested confrontation.

Loading article...