ALSO ON THE CREATOR SITERead this on pearloakes.avalw.comOpen

Sixpenny in Stanmore and Saint Peter in Paddington are the only two restaurants in Sydney to hold three hats for 2026. It is a narrow club, but the rest of the city is moving fast. The 42nd annual Sydney Morning Herald Good Food Guide has just dropped, and it is not the same list we saw last year. The guide has officially widened its net, moving away from a strict hierarchy of white tablecloths toward a broader definition of what constitutes a great meal.

This shift is not just semantic. It is structural. According to the guide, 35 new venues have earned their first hat this year. That is a massive injection of fresh talent into a market that has often felt static. The anonymous critics, who number around 40, have been visiting more than 500 restaurants across New South Wales and the ACT. They are no longer just looking for perfection in plating. They are looking for the specific experience a venue aims to achieve, a distinction that changes how we think about value and quality.

Scoring the Experience

The methodology behind the hats has always been precise, but the application has evolved. Each restaurant is scored out of a maximum of 20 points. The breakdown is specific: up to 10 points for the food itself, five for hospitality, three for the setting and overall experience, and two for value. To earn one hat, a venue needs at least 15 points. Two hats require 16 or 17. The three hat tier, the pinnacle of the guide, is reserved for the elite scoring between 18 and 20.

Co editor David Matthews made it clear that the 2026 awards were not about marking restaurants against some imagined metric of fanciness. The reviewers were explicitly asked to consider the dining experience each venue aimed to achieve. This means a casual spot with exceptional food and genuine hospitality can now compete on the same footing as a formal fine dining establishment. The guide is trying to reflect what modern diners actually want, which is often less about the cut of the silverware and more about the honesty of the plate.

The focus on value and hospitality extends to casual dining venues like Felons Seafood.
The focus on value and hospitality extends to casual dining venues like Felons Seafood.

The New Two Hat Club

Ten restaurants have jumped straight into the two hat category, a significant leap for any new or recently established venue. The list is geographically diverse, spanning from the Central Business District to the coastal suburbs. Lee Ho Fook in the CBD is a notable addition, bringing Victor Liong’s high standards to a new location. South End in Newtown and Stanley on Manly Wharf round out a group that represents the current pulse of Sydney’s dining scene.

Other newcomers in this tier include Ashe in the CBD and Flaminia in Circular Quay. These are not minor additions. They are strong contenders that are setting a new benchmark for consistency and quality. The fact that they are joining the two hat club alongside established names signals that the bar is high, but the door is open. It is a testament to the depth of talent currently operating in the state.

Hospitality is a key component of the 2026 scoring criteria, worth up to five points.
Hospitality is a key component of the 2026 scoring criteria, worth up to five points.

One Hat, New Faces

The one hat category has seen a surge, with 25 new restaurants joining the ranks. This is where the breadth of the 2026 guide is most visible. The list includes a wide array of cuisines and price points, from Besa in Bondi to Claret Club in Darlinghurst. There is a strong representation of seafood and casual dining, with Felons Seafood in Manly and Farmhouse Kings Cross in Rushcutters Bay both earning recognition.

You also see new names like Aenza and Avia in Darlinghurst, and Arthur in Surry Hills. These venues are capturing the attention of the anonymous reviewers by delivering on their specific promises. Whether that promise is a particular type of seafood, a specific culinary style, or a unique atmosphere, the guide is rewarding the execution. It is a reminder that great food does not need to be expensive to be exceptional.

The guide now includes cafes, pubs and bars, reflecting a broader definition of dining.
The guide now includes cafes, pubs and bars, reflecting a broader definition of dining.

What It Means for Diners

For the average food lover in Sydney, this announcement is a map. The 2026 Good Food Guide is less a list of elite clubs and more a directory of quality. The inclusion of cafes, pubs and bars alongside traditional restaurants shows that the industry is moving toward a more integrated dining culture. The line between a meal and a drink, or a casual bite and a full dinner, is blurring, and the guide is acknowledging that reality.

The focus on value and hospitality over sheer cost is a welcome change. It encourages diners to explore beyond the obvious hotspots. The 35 new hat winners are likely to see a significant boost in popularity, as the guide is a trusted source for many locals and visitors. It is a snapshot of a city that is hungry for innovation, authenticity, and a fair shake for venues that do things differently.

The Road Ahead

As we move through 2026, these 35 new additions will be under the microscope. The pressure to maintain a high standard is real, especially for those who have just entered the two hat tier. The guide is a moving target, and next year’s list will likely see further changes as new restaurants open and existing ones evolve. But for now, the 2026 list stands as a definitive record of where Sydney’s dining scene is right now.

It is a list that rewards ambition and execution. It is a list that reflects the changing tastes of a city that is no longer content with just one type of fine dining. Whether you are a regular at Saint Peter or a first timer at a new one hat spot in Newtown, the message is clear. The best food in Sydney is more diverse, more accessible, and more exciting than ever before.

Frequently asked questions

How many restaurants in Sydney hold three hats for 2026?

Only two restaurants in Sydney hold three hats for the 2026 Good Food Guide. These venues are Sixpenny in Stanmore and Saint Peter in Paddington.

What is the minimum score required to earn one hat in the 2026 guide?

A venue needs at least 15 points out of a maximum of 20 to earn one hat. This threshold is lower than the 16 or 17 points required for two hats and the 18 to 20 points reserved for the three hat tier.

Which new restaurants joined the two hat category in 2026?

Ten restaurants entered the two hat club, including Lee Ho Fook in the CBD, South End in Newtown, and Stanley on Manly Wharf. Other newcomers in this tier are Ashe in the CBD and Flaminia in Circular Quay.

How do the anonymous critics evaluate restaurants for the Good Food Guide?

Reviewers score venues out of 20 points based on food, hospitality, setting, and value. They are instructed to judge the specific dining experience a venue aims to achieve rather than strictly assessing formality or plating perfection.

How many new venues earned their first hat in the 2026 edition?

35 new venues earned their first hat this year. This group includes 25 one hat winners and 10 two hat additions, representing a significant injection of fresh talent into the guide.

What is the breakdown of the scoring system for the Good Food Guide?

The maximum score is 20 points, with up to 10 points allocated for the food itself. Hospitality accounts for five points, the setting and overall experience for three points, and value for two points.


Comments

0
No responses yet. Be the first to add one.
Pearl Oakes
Follow this desk
Pearl Oakes
Create a free account to follow Pearl Oakes. New stories land in your feed, and you can save any of them to your own reading lists.
Your library & lists →

Check this story

Verify
Ask AI