NYC homeowners get letters warning of new surcharge on secondary homes worth over $5 million

New York City's Department of Finance has published a public list of properties across the five boroughs and begun sending letters to homeowners warning they may be on the hook for a secondary tax on their property. The new surcharge targets secondary properties worth more than $5 million and applies unless owners can prove the home is their primary and permanent residence. The city estimates the measure could raise $500 million to help make up for a hefty budget loss. But lifelong New Yorkers say they are receiving the letters anyway, demanding proof of their residence, sparking concerns over the process. The Department of Finance says it used existing, possibly outdated information to determine residency status and stresses the supplemental roll includes all residential properties, not a targeted list. Homeowners who received a letter can submit an exemption application by August 21st for residential homes and condos, and by August 24th for co-ops.

A wave of letters from New York City's tax authority has left some homeowners worried they could owe more on their properties. The city's Department of Finance recently published a public list of the properties across the five boroughs, and the agency then began sending letters out to homeowners warning that they may be on the hook for paying a secondary tax on their property.

The catch, according to the city, is residency. Homeowners face the extra charge if they cannot prove that the property is their primary and permanent residence, turning the question of where someone actually lives into the deciding factor for whether the new tax applies.

The measure is aimed at high-end real estate. The new surcharge targets secondary properties worth more than $5 million, focusing on the upper end of the city's housing market rather than on ordinary homes occupied by their owners year round.

For the city, the appeal is the money it could bring in. The surcharge is estimated to raise $500 million for the city, revenue meant to help make up for a hefty budget loss that has left officials looking for new sources of income.

The rollout, however, has caused unease. Lifelong New Yorkers say they are receiving these letters anyway, with the notices demanding proof of their residence, and that has been sparking concerns over the process among people who consider the city their only home.

The Department of Finance has tried to explain how so many owners ended up flagged. The agency says it used existing information, possibly outdated, to determine residency status, and officials stressed that the mailing is broad rather than pointed. As one official put it, even a homeowner working on the issue could appear on the list: "You will find even myself on this supplemental role because I am a homeowner. So it is all residential properties on this supplemental role," the official said, calling it a misconception that the list is a targeted set of those actually facing the non-primary resident surcharge.

For those who did get a notice, there is a way to push back before the charge takes hold. Homeowners who received the letter stating they may be hit with the surcharge can submit an exemption application by August 21st for residential homes and condos, while for co-ops the deadline is August 24th.

Loading article...