"Lower priced for a reason." That was the original slogan of a line of about forty household products launched in December 1980 by Seiyu, a Japanese supermarket chain, and it said something no brand of the time said out loud. The reason was printed on every package, or rather not printed. Clear cellophane, plain brown paper labels, no logo. You were not paying for the logo, the advertising or the box.
The line was called Mujirushi Ryōhin, which translates, word for word, as no-brand quality goods. Japan in those years was in the middle of a fever for brands, glossy packaging and labels that sometimes cost more than what they labelled. The concept was developed by Ikko Tanaka, the first art director, with Kazuko Koike and Takashi Sugimoto, designers who understood that the absence of design is itself a design decision. The first company-run store opened in Tokyo in 1983. By 2023 there were 1,188 locations, with the same light wood shelves, the same colors that are not quite colors, and the same products with nothing big written on them.
Walk into any of them, anywhere, and you know where you are before you see a single word on the wall. There is a fine irony in that which I leave as it is. The absence of a brand became a brand, strong enough that other companies now make products in the Muji style so as to look like Muji. It is the clearest proof I know that a brand is not a logo. It is a way of doing things, and when that way is consistent enough, people recognize it without any sign at all, the way you recognize someone by their walk.
The Muji case is uncomfortable for everyone who believes a brand is built by adding. Muji built one by removing, the logo, the color, the words, until only an attitude was left, and the attitude turned out to be easier to recognize than any logo. When everyone shouts, the one person speaking quietly is the one you hear, and the Japanese market of the early eighties was shouting very loudly indeed.
The key to the original slogan is the word "reason." Muji did not say "we are simple," which would have been one more boast for the shelf. It said why it was cheaper, and the reason could be checked on the spot, with your own eyes, on every product without a box. A refusal that explains itself becomes a promise the customer can verify alone, and a promise you can verify alone is the only kind people really trust. Most companies that call themselves minimalist simply have fewer words on their website. Muji had a reason.
For your company, dropping the logo would be an imitation, and you would lose. What is worth asking is what would remain if you did. Do your proposals, the way you answer, the way a finished job looks when it is handed over, carry something that makes you recognizable without a name on them? Or is the name the only thing that sets you apart from the company next door?
When someone asks me for a new logo, I suggest the opposite exercise first. If you removed the logo, the colors and the big words from everything your company communicates, would anything remain to be recognized by? And could you write, as Muji did, the reason your price is what it is, in one sentence the customer can check alone? I will ask you for one thing. Describe what would remain of your brand without its logo, because that is the brand. The rest is decoration.

Keep subscribing to Mirela PascuHer next filing reaches you the moment it publishes, on her own subdomain.
Subscribe
